The OEP has today (Wednesday, November 18) confirmed that it has found that the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) Secretary of State (SoS) and Natural England are failing to meet their legal requirements to protect wild birds.
Latest statistics show that UK wild bird populations have dropped to their lowest level on record, with 45% of 132 native breeding species in decline over a five-year period. This includes much-loved species such as swifts, turtle doves, tree sparrows, wood warblers and bullfinches. At the same time, the nation’s interest in wild birds continues to grow. In May the RSPB reported a 47% increase in the number of people enjoying bird watching over the past eight years.
Government has legal responsibilities to take action to recover bird populations to healthy levels, as well as specific duties to designate Special Protection Areas (SPAs) for them. These SPAs are areas of land or sea with strict legal protections to safeguard rare and vulnerable birds during migration, breeding and over-wintering. The Severn Estuary and The Wash demonstrate the importance of England’s SPAs, with the latter regularly supporting over 400,000 waterbirds over the winter.
As part of an ongoing investigation, the OEP has now issued Defra and Natural England with decision notices setting out its findings, detailing where it has identified failures to comply with environmental law. The notices also set out the actions they need to take in order to meet their legal obligations.
In part, the failures to comply with environmental law identified by the OEP relate to measures recommended to ensure the SPA network is sufficient to achieve its intended outcomes identified as far back as 2001, but which remain unimplemented.
Helen Venn, Chief Regulatory Officer for the OEP, said: “As a nation of bird-lovers, and with birds acting as important indicators for the state of our nature more widely, the latest statistics showing declines in the populations of some of our most treasured species are deeply concerning.
“This is why it is important that Defra and Natural England do carry out their legal responsibilities in a reasonable timeframe to deliver nature recovery and in relation to the classification and adaptation of SPAs on land.
“Continued delay has left a significant number of sites for wild bird populations without the levels of protection they need and allowed the scale of the actions needed to deliver a sufficient SPA network to build up.
“SPAs also have wider importance and have a role to play in achieving government’s wider environmental commitments, such as the goal of restored nature in its Environmental Improvement Plan, legally binding targets on species abundance and the commitment to protect at least 30% of land and seas for nature’s recovery by 2030."
As a whole, breeding wild bird populations across the UK are showing no sign of widespread recovery, with both short and long term trends indicating that nearly half of all species are in decline, according to Defra’s latest statistics.
The OEP concluded in June 2025 that there may have been failures to comply with environmental law and issued Defra and Natural England with information notices setting out the details of its findings. The decision notices are the next step in the OEP’s investigation. They set out what actions the OEP considers Defra and Natural England should now take to fix the failures. They have two months to respond to the decision notices and the OEP will consider their responses before deciding next steps.
Ms Venn added: “We welcome the positive steps that are now being taken to address some of our concerns. These could help address some of the issues we have identified for the SPA network and for threatened wild birds more widely.
“This includes Natural England’s forthcoming programme for future designations and their action planning, in partnership with Defra, to recover species on the basis of its Threatened Species Recovery Actions database. There has also been constructive engagement with Natural England on what the law requires which has helped provide a stronger basis for the action that we now consider needs to follow.
“However, our investigation has identified that more work needs to be done. By issuing these decision notices we seek to ensure all that should be done is being done at a pace that will better protect and improve these key habitats so wild birds can thrive, as the law intended.”
The OEP will aim to resolve any non-compliance through co-operation, dialogue and agreement with public departments and authorities.
Where a satisfactory outcome cannot be reached through these means, the OEP can use its other enforcement powers including, if necessary, commencing court proceedings.
A parallel investigation is looking at the same issues involving the Department for Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs (DAERA) in Northern Ireland, and it has also been issued with a decision notice.
Environmental Standards Scotland (ESS) and the Interim Environmental Protection Assessor for Wales (IEPAW) have also been considering issues around SPAs and have been kept up to date with the OEP’s findings.